Here’s Marty & Shannon’s Milkshake Recipe from Dairy Day at the NYS Fair

Thursday was Dairy Day at The Great New York State Fair and all the local media town got together to compete and take bragging rights for Best Milkshake!

95X’s Marty & Shannon from The Morning Mess took part and entered their creation, The Choconutterbutterscotch! We had high hopes for them buuut…. well they lost.

We didn’t think it sucked that bad so we want you to be the judge. Here’s the recipe for The Choconutterbutterscotch.¬†Go ahead and try it at home and just see how good it is — or don’t.


The Choconutterbutterscotch

  • Vanilla Ice Cream
  • Whole Milk
  • Butterscotch Sauce

Blend until nice and creamy and butterscotchy. Add a couple of nutter butters and blend some more. Drizzle chocolate sauce, peanut butter sauce, and more butterscotch sauce in cup. Layer shake, sauces drizzled, Shake, sauces, shake. Whipped cream. Crumbled nutter butter and one whole cookie. Drizzle sauces.


– Marty & Shannon